-
Who this checklist is for
-
Seven steps. Use this order.
-
Step 1 — Freeze your datasheet before you ask for prices
-
Step 2 — Verify the manufacturer, not just the supplier
-
Step 3 — Write design responsibility into the contract
-
Step 4 — Split installation scope out on its own
-
Step 5 — Pressure-test the documentation package before the P.O.
-
Step 6 — Check certificates, not “compliance statements”
-
Step 7 — Lock FAT and SAT acceptance criteria up front
-
Step 1 — Freeze your datasheet before you ask for prices
-
What most people miss
Who this checklist is for
This is for anyone buying reactors, heat exchangers, columns, tanks, or skid-mounted units. Seven steps, in order, one sourcing cycle. It won't make you a process engineer. But it will get you around the mistakes I made personally between 2016 and now—roughly $40,000 in wasted budget across four projects.
The worst one: in 2019 we paid $18,400 for a heat exchanger where the nameplate heat duty was pulled from an old datasheet and nobody caught it until the installation crew looked at the drawing and said “this can't be what you ordered.” Line down for two weeks. I keep the checklist on my wall now.
Accurate as of Q2 2025. Material pricing, acceptance code editions, and lead times move fast — verify current figures before you commit.
Seven steps. Use this order.
Step 1 — Freeze your datasheet before you ask for prices
The most skipped step. Most buyers open the RFQ as soon as they get a keyword, so every quote sits on different assumptions and looks comparable when it isn't. You end up comparing prices when you're really comparing seven different guesses.
What to do: sit down with process, equipment, and HSE and lock these seven things — design pressure, design temperature, medium, corrosion allowance, nozzle sizes, flange standard, materials. Then send the RFQ. This costs nothing and blocks about 80% of downstream rework.
Checkpoint: version number, signer, and date on the datasheet. Any line marked “TBC” — do not send it.
Step 2 — Verify the manufacturer, not just the supplier
The hardest distinction in chemical process equipment sourcing is “supplier” vs “manufacturer.” Plenty of companies listed as a chemical process equipment manufacturer are actually trading companies. That's not inherently bad, but you need to know who actually takes your money and who actually owns the welding.
In 2021 we awarded a tank order to a supplier who quoted fast. Site audit revealed they had no rolling shop — everything was subcontracted to a third party. Perfectly legal, but the top-level control over weld quality was gone.
What I ask now:
- Shop photos or a short video, ideally with today's date visible
- What they make in-house vs. outsource — written, itemized
- Who signs the WPS/PQR, and where that person works
Three questions. Half the “pseudo-manufacturers” out themselves.
Step 3 — Write design responsibility into the contract
Design is where disputes live. Buyer thinks the supplier is doing the design; supplier thinks the buyer supplied the final datasheet. Then the equipment can't be installed and everyone is quoting the purchase order at each other.
In 2018 we ordered a glass-lined reactor. Contract only said “fabricated per buyer datasheet.” Nobody wrote who does the strength calculation, who signs, who owns the as-built. The agitator shaft overhang didn't line up — 3 weeks rework, $6,700 gone.
At minimum, the contract needs:
- Who produces the design documents
- Who reviews and signs off
- Change order route and who pays
I'd rather over-write this section than argue about it later. Which is to say, the cheapest sentence in the whole contract is the one you added before signing.
Step 4 — Split installation scope out on its own
Most chemical process equipment quotes say “installation support included” without saying what that means — one engineer for a visit, or a full crew for two weeks. If you don't ask, the default is the minimum.
In 2022 we bought two shell-and-tube exchangers. Quote said “installation support included.” What arrived was one technician for two days. Pipe alignment, leveling, and hydrotest were on us — $4,200 to bring in a third party mid-project.
Confirm three things:
- Number of days on site
- Which activities require presence (lift, alignment, pressure test)
- Rate for days beyond the included block
Chemical process equipment installation isn't an accessory line. Treat it as its own procurement item with its own checklist.
Step 5 — Pressure-test the documentation package before the P.O.
The step I paid the most for. The equipment itself was fine — the paperwork wasn't. At client acceptance we found missing material certificates, incomplete NDT reports, and a spare parts list that didn't match what shipped.
In 2020 we delivered a $11,000 skid. Equipment was basically perfect. Package was missing two NDT reports. Three weeks to get the client's signed acceptance. Those three weeks of project delay cost more than the reports did.
Before P.O.: ask for a document list, with delivery milestones for each file. Don't wait until FAT day to ask what's in the package.
Step 6 — Check certificates, not “compliance statements”
“Material meets the requirement” — that sentence proves nothing. What you want is an MTC (material test certificate) with a heat number, the original mill's name, and a heat number that traces to the actual nameplate.
I once saw a compliance statement that was a generic template with a company stamp on it. We picked one head at random and the heat number didn't show up in the certificate. Entire batch replaced.
How to reconcile:
- Heat number on each MTC ↔ heat number stenciled on the part
- Original producer name on the MTC ↔ your approved supplier list
- Pressure-retaining parts — require 3.1 or 3.2 certificates
Ugly work. Catches most substitution issues.
Step 7 — Lock FAT and SAT acceptance criteria up front
The real FAT risk isn't that something goes wrong. It's that the criteria were never written, so when something goes wrong nobody can say whether it counts.
2017, first project I ran solo. Nobody wrote FAT acceptance items. On the floor I asked the tech lead “does this line slope pass?” He looked and said “looks OK.” We signed. Three months later at commissioning, condensate wasn't draining. Rework.
What works:
- 10–15 explicit acceptance items, quantified where possible
- Method, tool, referenced document, and pass threshold per item
- A signature page that says who signs and what signing means
Draft this during P.O. negotiation, not the day before FAT.
What most people miss
One — don't anchor on the lowest price. In chemical process equipment sourcing, the equipment price is usually the easiest part to audit. Installation support, documentation terms, and warranty period are the hidden columns. Split every quote into four columns — equipment, installation, documents, warranty — and compare total cost. Never the sticker.
Two — say it out loud on timing. This was written in Q2 2025. Raw material index, FX, and code edition updates will shift by the time you read it. Cross-check against this year's numbers before you budget anything.
Three — commit dates vs. promises. A promised lead time and an actual lead time are two different things. Ask for the production schedule — when cutting starts, when welding starts. No schedule means the date is a hope, not a plan.
If you only have energy for two steps: Step 5 and Step 7. Documents and acceptance criteria are the two that bite hardest at the tail end of a project, right when everyone is out of patience and the budget is already thin.
Once you've run this checklist on one project, the next RFQ takes an afternoon instead of three weeks of chasing loose ends. That's the whole argument. Efficiency isn't about going fast — it's about not paying twice for the same lesson.